A reanalysis of football impact reconstructions for head kinematics and finite element modeling

      Abstract

      Background

      Head kinematics generated by laboratory reconstructions of professional football helmet impacts have been applied to computational models to study the biomechanics of concussion. Since the original publication of this data, techniques for evaluating accelerometer consistency and error correction have been developed. This study applies these techniques to the original reconstruction data and reanalyzes the results given the current state of concussion biomechanics.

      Methods

      Consistency checks were applied to the sensor data collected in the head of each test dummy. Inconsistent data were corrected using analytical techniques, and head kinematics were recalculated from the corrected data. Reconstruction videos were reviewed to identify artefactual impacts during the reconstruction to establish the region of applicability for simulations. Corrected head kinematics were input into finite element brain models to investigate strain response to the corrected dataset.

      Findings

      Multiple reconstruction cases had inconsistent sensor arrays caused by a problematic sensor; corrections to the arrays caused changes in calculated rotational head motion. These corrections increased median peak angular velocity for the concussion cases from 35.6 to 41.5 rad/s. Using the original kinematics resulted in an average error of 20% in maximum principal strain results for each case. Simulations of the reconstructions also demonstrated that simulation lengths less than 40 ms did not capture the entire brain strain response and under-predicted strain.

      Interpretation

      This study corrects data that were used to determine concussion risk, and indicates altered head angular motion and brain strain response for many reconstructions. Conclusions based on the original data should be re-examined based on this new study.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment
      Subscribe to Clinical Biomechanics
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Bandak F.A.
        On the mechanics of impact neurotrauma: a review and critical synthesis.
        J. Neurotrauma. 1995; 12: 635-649
        • Bonita R.
        • Beaglehole R.
        • Kjellström T.
        Basic epidemiology.
        World Health Organization, 2006
        • Broglio S.P.
        • Schnebel B.
        • Sosnoff J.J.
        • Shin S.
        • Feng X.
        • He X.
        • Zimmerman J.
        Biomechanical properties of concussions in high school football.
        Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 2010; 42: 2064-2071https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0b013e3181dd9156
        • Chamouard F.
        • Trosseille X.
        • Pincemaille Y.
        • Tarriere C.
        Methodological aspects of an experimental research on cerebral tolerance on the basis of boxers' training fights.
        1987 (SAE Technical Paper)
        • Chatelin S.
        • Constantinesco A.
        • Willinger R.
        Fifty years of brain tissue mechanical testing: from in vitro to in vivo investigations.
        Biorheology. 2010; : 255-276https://doi.org/10.3233/BIR-2010-0576
        • Duma S.M.
        • Manoogian S.J.
        • Bussone W.R.
        • Brolinson P.G.
        • Goforth M.W.
        • Donnenwerth J.J.
        • Greenwald R.M.
        • Chu J.J.
        • Crisco J.J.
        Analysis of real-time head accelerations in collegiate football players.
        Clin. J. Sport Med. 2005; 15: 3-8
        • Funk J.R.
        • Duma S.M.
        • Manoogian S.J.
        • Rowson S.
        Biomechanical risk estimates for mild traumatic brain injury.
        Annu. Proc. Assoc. Adv. Automot. Med. 2007; 51: 343-361
        • Funk J.R.
        • Rowson S.
        • Daniel R.W.
        • Duma S.M.
        Validation of concussion risk curves for collegiate football players derived from HITS data.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2012; 40: 79-89
        • Gabler L.F.
        • Crandall J.R.
        • Panzer M.B.
        Assessment of kinematic brain injury metrics for predicting strain responses in diverse automotive impact conditions.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. Rev. 2016; 44: 3705-3718
        • Ghajari M.
        • Hellyer P.J.
        • Sharp D.J.
        Computational modelling of traumatic brain injury predicts the location of chronic traumatic encephalopathy pathology.
        Brain. 2017; 140: 333-343https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/aww317
        • Giordano C.
        • Kleiven S.
        Evaluation of axonal strain as a predictor for mild traumatic brain injuries using finite element modeling.
        Stapp Car Crash J. 2014; 58: 29
        • Giordano C.
        • Zappalà S.
        • Kleiven S.
        Anisotropic finite element models for brain injury prediction: the sensitivity of axonal strain to white matter tract inter-subject variability.
        Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 2017; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10237-017-0887-5
        • Ho J.
        • Kleiven S.
        Can sulci protect the brain from traumatic injury?.
        J. Biomech. 2009; 42: 2074-2080https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2009.06.051
        • Ho J.
        • Zhou Z.
        • Li X.
        • Kleiven S.
        The peculiar properties of the falx and tentorium in brain injury biomechanics.
        J. Biomech. 2017; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2017.06.023
        • Jadischke R.
        • Viano D.C.
        • Dau N.
        • King A.I.
        • McCarthy J.
        On the accuracy of the head impact telemetry (HIT) system used in football helmets.
        J. Biomech. 2013; 46: 2310-2315
        • Ji S.
        • Ghadyani H.
        • Bolander R.P.
        • Beckwith J.G.
        • Ford J.C.
        • McAllister T.W.
        • Flashman L.A.
        • Paulsen K.D.
        • Ernstrom K.
        • Jain S.
        Parametric comparisons of intracranial mechanical responses from three validated finite element models of the human head.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2014; 42: 11-24
        • Kang H.-S.
        • Willinger R.
        • Diaw B.M.
        • Chinn B.
        Validation of a 3D anatomic human head model and replication of head impact in motorcycle accident by finite element modeling.
        in: Proceedings: Stapp Car Crash Conference. Society of Automotive Engineers SAE. 1997: 329-338
        • Kimpara H.
        • Iwamoto M.
        Mild traumatic brain injury predictors based on angular accelerations during impacts.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2012; 40: 114-126
        • King A.I.
        • Yang K.H.
        • Zhang L.
        • Hardy W.
        • Viano D.C.
        Is head injury caused by linear or angular acceleration.
        in: Proceedings of the International Research Conference on the Biomechanics of Impacts (IRCOBI). 2003: 1-12
        • Kleiven S.
        Predictors for traumatic brain injuries evaluated through accident reconstructions.
        Stapp Car Crash J. 2007; 51: 81-114
        • Langlois J.A.
        • Rutland-Brown W.
        • Wald M.M.
        The epidemiology and impact of traumatic brain injury: a brief overview.
        J. Head Trauma Rehabil. 2006; 21: 375-378
        • Mao H.
        • Zhang L.
        • Jiang B.
        • Genthikatti V.V.
        • Jin X.
        • Zhu F.
        • Makwana R.
        • Gill A.
        • Jandir G.
        • Singh A.
        Development of a finite element human head model partially validated with thirty five experimental cases.
        J. Biomech. Eng. 2013; 135111002
        • Mihalik J.P.
        • Bell D.R.
        • Marshall S.W.
        • Guskiewicz K.M.
        Measurement of head impacts in collegiate football players: an investigation of positional and event-type differences.
        Neurosurgery. 2007; 61: 1229-1235https://doi.org/10.1227/01.neu.0000306101.83882.c8
        • Newman J.
        • Beusenberg M.
        • Fournier E.
        • Shewchenko N.
        • Withnall C.
        • King A.
        • Yang K.
        • Zhang L.
        • McElhaney J.
        • Thibault L.
        A new biomechanical assessment of mild traumatic brain injury. Part 1 - methodology.
        in: Proceedings of the International Research Conference on the Biomechanics of Impacts (IRCOBI). International Research Council on Biomechanics of Injury, Sitges, Spain. 1999: 17-36
        • Newman J.
        • Barr C.
        • Beusenberg M.
        • Fournier E.
        • Shewchenko N.
        • Welbourne E.
        • Withnall C.
        A New Biomechanical Assessment of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury. Part 2 - Results and Conclusions, Proceedings of the International Research Conference on the Biomechanics of Impacts (IRCOBI) International Research Council on Biomechanics of Injury, Montpellier, France2000: 223-233
        • Newman J.A.
        • Beusenberg M.C.
        • Shewchenko N.
        • Withnall C.
        • Fournier E.
        Verification of biomechanical methods employed in a comprehensive study of mild traumatic brain injury and the effectiveness of American football helmets.
        J. Biomech. 2005; 38: 1469-1481https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2004.06.025
        • Padgaonkar A.J.
        • Krieger K.W.
        • King A.I.
        Measurement of angular acceleration of a rigid body using linear accelerometers.
        J. Appl. Mech. 1975; 42: 552-556https://doi.org/10.1115/1.3423640
        • Panzer M.B.
        • Myers B.S.
        • Capehart B.P.
        • Bass C.R.
        Development of a finite element model for blast brain injury and the effects of CSF cavitation.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2012; 40: 1530-1544https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-012-0519-2
        • Patton D.A.
        A review of instrumented equipment to investigate head impacts in sport.
        Appl. Bionics Biomech. 2016; 2016: 1-16https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/7049743
        • Pellman E.J.
        • Viano D.C.
        • Tucker A.M.
        • Casson I.R.
        • Waeckerle J.F.
        Concussion in professional football: reconstruction of game impacts and injuries.
        Neurosurgery. 2003; 53: 799-814
        • Rowson B.
        • Rowson S.
        • Duma S.M.
        Hockey STAR: a methodology for assessing the biomechanical performance of hockey helmets.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2015; 43: 2429-2443https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-015-1278-7
        • Sanchez E.J.
        • Gabler L.F.
        • McGhee J.S.
        • Olszko A.V.
        • Chancey V.C.
        • Crandall J.R.
        • Panzer M.B.
        Evaluation of head and brain injury risk functions using sub-injurious human volunteer data.
        J. Neurotrauma. 2017; https://doi.org/10.1089/neu.2016.4681
        • Sanchez E.
        • Gabler L.
        • Rowson B.
        • Rowson S.
        • Duma S.
        • Panzer M.
        Brain Strain Patterns Associated with Football Impact Reconstructions.
        Journal of Neurotrauma. Mary Ann Liebert, Inc, 2017: A30-A31
        • Schnebel B.
        • Gwin J.T.
        • Anderson S.
        • Gatlin R.
        In vivo study of head impacts in football: a comparison of national collegiate athletic association division I versus high school impacts.
        Neurosurgery. 2007; 60: 490-496https://doi.org/10.1227/01.NEU.0000249286.92255.7F
        • Siegmund G.P.
        • Guskiewicz K.M.
        • Marshall S.W.
        • DeMarco A.L.
        • Bonin S.J.
        Laboratory validation of two wearable sensor systems for measuring head impact severity in football players.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2015; : 1-18
        • Takhounts E.G.
        • Ridella S.A.
        • Hasija V.
        • Tannous R.E.
        • Campbell J.Q.
        • Malone D.
        • Danelson K.
        • Stitzel J.
        • Rowson S.
        • Duma S.
        Investigation of traumatic brain injuries using the next generation of simulated injury monitor (SIMon) finite element head model.
        Stapp Car Crash J. 2008; 52: 1
        • Takhounts E.G.
        • Hasija V.
        • Eppinger R.H.
        Analysis of 3D Rigid Body Motion Using the nine Accelerometer Array and the Randomly Distributed in-plane Accelerometer Systems, in: Proceedings of International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicle.
        Germany, Stuttgart2009
        • Takhounts E.G.
        • Craig C.
        • Matthew J.
        • Moorhouse K.
        • McFadden J.
        • Hasija V.
        Development of brain injury criteria (BrIC).
        Stapp Car Crash J. 2013; 57: 243-266
        • Viano D.C.
        • Casson I.R.
        • Pellman E.J.
        • Zhang L.
        • King A.I.
        • Yang K.H.
        Concussion in professional football: brain responses by finite element analysis: part 9.
        Neurosurgery. 2005; 57: 891-916https://doi.org/10.1227/01.NEU.0000186950.54075.3B
        • Willinger R.
        • Baumgartner D.
        Human head tolerance limits to specific injury mechanisms.
        Int. J. Crashworthiness. 2003; 8: 605-617
        • Zhang L.
        • Yang K.H.
        • King A.I.
        A proposed injury threshold for mild traumatic brain injury.
        J. Biomech. Eng. 2004; 126: 226-236
        • Zhao W.
        • Cai Y.
        • Li Z.
        • Ji S.
        Injury prediction and vulnerability assessment using strain and susceptibility measures of the deep white matter.
        Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 2017; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10237-017-0915-5
        • Zhao W.
        • Kuo C.
        • Wu L.
        • Camarillo D.B.
        • Ji S.
        Performance evaluation of a pre-computed brain response atlas in dummy head impacts.
        Ann. Biomed. Eng. 2017; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-017-1888-3